Freud claimed that religious beliefs were illusions. What did he mean by "illusion"?
Freud claimed that religious beliefs were illusions. What did he mean by "illusion"?
An "illusion," as Freud uses the term, is a belief rooted in our wishes and feelings. An illusion needn't be false. He gives the example of a poor girl who believes (based on her wishes and feelings) that a prince will come and marry her; this is an illusion -- even if in fact it turns out to be true.
So in claiming that religious beliefs are illusions, Freud is saying that they are based on our wishes and feelings. He isn't saying that they are necessarily false. But he does say that they are, from an intellectual standpoint, groundless -- because they aren't based on experience and reason.
Freud claimed that religious beliefs were illusions. What did he mean by "illusion"?
An "illusion," as Freud uses the term, is a belief rooted in our wishes and feelings. An illusion needn't be false. He gives the example of a poor girl who believes (based on her wishes and feelings) that a prince will come and marry her; this is an illusion -- even if in fact it turns out to be true.
So in claiming that religious beliefs are illusions, Freud is saying that they are based on our wishes and feelings. He isn't saying that they are necessarily false. But he does say that they are, from an intellectual standpoint, groundless -- because they aren't based on experience and reason.
Freud claimed that religious beliefs were illusions. What did he mean by "illusion"?
An "illusion," as Freud uses the term, is a belief rooted in our wishes and feelings. An illusion needn't be false. He gives the example of a poor girl who believes (based on her wishes and feelings) that a prince will come and marry her; this is an illusion -- even if in fact it turns out to be true.
So in claiming that religious beliefs are illusions, Freud is saying that they are based on our wishes and feelings. He isn't saying that they are necessarily false. But he does say that they are, from an intellectual standpoint, groundless -- because they aren't based on experience and reason.